All prices were accurate at the time of publishing. My personal favorite is the $5 clear glass gingerbread house cookie jar, which shoppers couldn’t get enough of when it hit shelves in October 2023.

This article may contain affiliate links that Yahoo and/or the publisher may receive a commission from if you buy a product ...

Red Vines Twists Original Chewy Candy, 3.5lbs Party Size Jar ($11) Mars Mixed Skittles & Starburst Variety Pack Chewy Candy Assortment -18 Bars Box ($20) Jelly Belly Monster Mash Mix Halloween Fun ...